My Shoes Are Squeaking. How Do I Fix It? Valisa R. August 14, 2017 17:31 We are sorry to hear that your shoes are squeaking. We make our shoes with removable inserts to allow you to further customize your shoe fit through the use of our upgraded insoles or an orthotic. Sometimes air or moisture can get trapped between the insert and the rest of the shoe that can cause a squeak. The fit of the orthotic in the shoe can cause friction and therefore noise as well.One possible solution is to remove the insoles and sprinkle some baby powder into the shoes. Leave the powder in your shoes overnight and in the morning empty out the excess powder. Another possible solution is to use sandpaper on the sides of the tongue to reduce friction which causes the noise.